The short answer
The right thermostat setting for a heat pump in winter is 68 degrees, left at a steady temperature. Unlike a gas furnace, turning a heat pump down at night can actually cost you more money because it triggers expensive auxiliary heat to warm the house back up in the morning.
Written by Comfort Systems of York County team
Last updated
Definition
Why do heat pumps need different thermostat settings?
Heat pumps work differently than standard gas furnaces. A gas furnace generates heat and blasts hot air to warm up a cold house. A heat pump moves ambient heat from the outside air into your home. Because it transfers heat instead of creating it, the system works well when it maintains a steady, even temperature.
If you turn the thermostat down 10 degrees at night, the heat pump has to work much harder to recover the next morning. It is designed for steady cruising, not acceleration. This is why the right approach for a heat pump is to set it and forget it.
When it applies
When should you adjust your heat pump temperature?
For winter heating, pick a comfortable temperature between 68 and 70 degrees and leave it there. You only need to lower the temperature if you are leaving town for a few days. If you have a smart thermostat, make sure it is configured specifically for a heat pump so it knows how to recover temperatures slowly.
In the summer, you can treat your heat pump exactly like a standard air conditioner. Setting it to 75 or 78 degrees while you are away and lowering it when you get home works perfectly fine for cooling. The steady temperature rule only applies to the winter heating season.
Failure modes
What happens if you turn the heat down at night?
If you lower your heat pump by more than two degrees at night and turn it up in the morning, the system thinks it is falling behind. To catch up, it automatically turns on the auxiliary heat.
- Auxiliary heat uses electric resistance strips to create heat.
- These strips use up to three times as much electricity as the heat pump itself.
- Relying on auxiliary heat for daily temperature recovery is the main reason homeowners see massive spikes in their winter power bills.
Proof
What do we see most often around York County?
We talk to a lot of new neighbors in Fort Mill and Indian Land who just moved here from colder states. They are used to gas furnaces and deep nighttime temperature setbacks. When they try that routine with their new heat pump, they get a shock on their first winter electric bill. We have been helping Rock Hill area homeowners run their systems efficiently since 1965. A steady thermostat setting keeps your home warm and keeps your power bills predictable.
Next step
What should you do next?
Set your thermostat to a comfortable winter temperature and leave it alone for a few days to see how your home feels. If your heat pump struggles to keep the house warm without running the auxiliary heat constantly, you might have an underlying issue. Call us to schedule a diagnostic visit. It is $89 during office hours, $129 after hours, or $69 for Comfort Club members. Our technicians will find the problem and explain the repair before any work begins.
Common questions
- Why does my thermostat say emergency heat?
- Emergency heat manually turns off the heat pump and only uses the electric resistance strips. You should only use this setting if the outdoor unit is completely broken or frozen solid.
- Is it normal for a heat pump to run all the time in winter?
- Yes. Heat pumps are designed to run continuously at a lower speed to maintain a steady temperature. As long as it is keeping the house warm and the auxiliary heat is not constantly on, continuous running is normal.
Where to go next
- Learn How a Heat Pump Works in the Carolinas
One machine that cools all summer and heats most of the winter, and why it suits the Piedmont climate.
- Learn Heat Pump Aux Heat vs Emergency Heat
Understand the difference between auxiliary and emergency heat, and when your heat pump should actually use them.
- Compare Heat Pump, Furnace, or Both? Dual Fuel Explained
How a heat pump and a gas furnace split the work, and when pairing them makes sense in York County.
- Service
- Heat pump repair
- Near you
- HVAC services in Fort Mill
- Next step
- Schedule Service
From our blog
← Back to the Learning Center HVAC glossary
How we wrote this: general guidance from Comfort Systems of York County, based on the work we do across York, Chester, and Lancaster Counties and the greater Charlotte area. It isn't a quote or a diagnosis. Every home is different, so a technician's inspection comes first.